Yesterday was the 11th anniversary of the “Battle of Hogwarts” and has become customary, JK Rowling tweeted out an apology for killing off a character during the battle. This year she chose someone outside the battle, but a character who died to save those who would win. Dobby, the house elf.
In general there seem to be two sides to the thought of killing characters. Either the author should respect the characters and their fictional lives making death only and option when no other is logical, feasible, or avoidable. The second, seemingly championed by George R. R. Martin and Robert Kirkman, is that no one is safe. Any character, at any time could be killed. My own feelings lie somewhere in between.
So far, in my writing, I have only killed off two characters. The first was in a story/book that isn’t finished or published. The second is the main character of a story called “Unfathomable”. While writing this story I speculated and teased the idea that my main character would survive with a horrific tale to tell of the sights he observed, but the more I thought about it the less that path felt right. It wasn’t as if I needed my main character to be sacrificial for the story to work, but in order to create the fear and tension required to put the reader in the small cramped submersible trapped in an underwater cave tracking down an undiscovered creature, his death was the only option.
I respect my characters. I put a lot of work into breathing life into each and every one of them. I strive to make them all unique in some way and doing so means that unless it serves the story I don’t plan on killing them off. But, that doesn’t mean that it is unavoidable. There are times where it will be necessary. And when death comes to a character I hope my readers will understand it wasn’t without cause or reason.
Rowling’s tweet yesterday frustrated me. In order for the Battle of Hogwarts to be epic and hold the weight it did, fictional lives had to be lost. Sad, though they may be. If everyone came out the other side with a few scratches, but otherwise unhurt, the fight wouldn’t have felt as big or as important. Going back now and apologizing for the deaths of characters as she does makes it seems as if she’s bowing to the will of a few disgruntled readers. In turn, compromising the story she wrote and in some ways minimizing the fictional lives and sacrifices of those characters.
As such, I promise never to apologize for the death of a character. If they die. It was necessary.